Last night brought us the three-hour (!!!) premiere of Heroes on the NBC television network. Hour one took us to a red carpet premiere party where the stars of the show, including an unnaturally tan Sylar, recapped the past seasons and previewed the new one. I was grateful for the recap, because I’d forgotten some key elements of the finale, including but not limited to: everything that happened in the finale and every episode that preceded it.
After the party, Sylar returned to his hotel room to inject himself with bronzer. The rest of us were treated to two episodes of the new season. Well, “treated” is not quite the right word. “Subjected to” maybe? However you phrase it, Heroes is lousy and I’m not sure it’s fixable.
You know what the problem is as well as I do — a show about gods is inherently dramaless, particularly when the gods are written as idiots. Too many characters are way too powerful, and the writers are completely backed into a corner.
Look no further than the first three minutes: Future Claire points a gun at Future Peter’s head, intending to kill him. Peter, you’ll recall, absorbs powers from other Heroes, and is as such omnipotent. Claire is quite aware of this. Nevertheless, she pulls the trigger. There is no way — NO WAY — you can spin this so it makes any sense. Claire isn’t stupid. Neither are we. Think of all the ways Peter could have beaten death:
- Stop time and move out of the bullet’s path (that’s what he did in the episode)
- Teleport behind Claire and snatch the gun away
- Phase out and let the bullet pass through him
- Fly over the bullet
- Use his mind powers to compel Claire to drop the gun
- Let the bullet hit him, and allow his body to heal itself (Claire’s very own power!!)
- Telekinesis the gun out of Claire’s hand
I’m sure I’m missing other possibilities, but you get my point. Over the course of these two episodes I must have said to myself “Why didn’t he/she just…” about 30 times. Why can’t Future Peter just go back in time and kill Sylar before he got his powers? Why didn’t Sylar rip the door off its hinges with his mind? Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. It’s odd to say this, considering this a show about superheroes, but Heroes isn’t realistic enough.
This all started back at the end of Season One, when Hiro just ran up to Sylar with a samurai sword and stabbed him in the heart. Sylar just kind of stood there, instead of using one of the many powers at his command to strike down Hiro. That was so disappointing, because the show had been so brilliant up to that point. It never really recovered.
(And are we really going to have another apocolypse this season? Really? Meh.)
At least we’ve got Bruce Boxleitner on the scene. Maybe he’ll save us. He has to.
Oh, and a special note to Greatest American Hero star William Katt, who graced the second episode last night: Bill, my friend, time to let that haircut go.